Story highlights
Ten state attorneys general delivered an ultimatum to the Trump administration
The administration has angered activists at both ends of the spectrum with its stance
President Donald Trump has let a controversial Obama-era immigration policy continue – and conservative states are running out of patience.
Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton was joined by his counterparts in nine other states in a letter Thursday warning Attorney General Jeff Sessions that if the Trump administration does not move to end Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals, they will file a court challenge to the program.
At the heart of the threat is ongoing litigation over a related program – giving the attorneys general an opening to squeeze the administration on DACA.
Despite explicitly pledging during the campaign to “immediately” rescind DACA, a program that gives undocumented immigrants brought to the US as children protection from deportation and the ability to work and study in the US, the Trump administration has continued to honor the program and issue new permits under it.
With its efforts, the administration appears to want to have it both ways, continuing the program and pledging to protect its participants while saying the situation isn’t necessarily permanent and arresting those who officials say have lost their DACA status. But that position has angered activists on both sides of the issue, who in a rare moment of agreement have expressed similar frustrations that the administration won’t clearly articulate its long-term plans for DACA.
At issue is pending litigation in Texas that has challenged an Obama administration program that’s similar to DACA but geared toward parents of childhood arrivals as well as an extension of the childhood arrivals program, both of which were never allowed to go into effect by the courts.
The Trump administration formally abandoned the Deferred Action for Parents of Americans and Lawful Permanent Residents program, known as DAPA, earlier this month to avoid having to defend it in court. But it left DACA on the books despite similar criticism of that program – namely that both programs were an overreach of executive authority.
Asked by CNN about that decision, Homeland Security Secretary John Kelly at the time called it “house cleaning,” saying the program for parents was blocked by the courts while the one for those who came to the US was children wasn’t.
But Paxton wrote that if the administration doesn’t end DACA by September 5, Texas will amend its complaint in the case to include that program – which would force the administration to defend the program in litigation or abandon it.
“We respectfully request that the Secretary of Homeland Security phase out the DACA program,” Paxton wrote in the ultimatum. “Otherwise, the complaint in that case will be amended to challenge both the DACA program and the remaining Expanded DACA permits.”
The Department of Justice and DHS did not respond to a request for comment on the letter. Sessions was asked about it on “Fox and Friends” on Friday and seemingly praised the states.
“The DAPA law has already been withdrawn,” Sessions said when asked what changes could be coming. “That was a big victory, and we’ll be looking at that. But I’ve got to tell you, I like it that our states and localities are holding the federal government to account, expecting us to do what is our responsibility to the state and locals, and that’s to enforce the law.”
Despite railing against DACA during the campaign, Trump showed a more sympathetic side side after his election.
“We’re going to show great heart,” Trump said in a news conference in February. “DACA is a very, very difficult subject for me, I will tell you.”
But he also spoke of possible abuses of the program.
“To me, it’s one of the most difficult subjects I have because you have these incredible kids, in many cases, not in all cases. And some of the cases, having DACA and they’re gang members and they’re drug dealers, too. But you have some absolutely incredible kids, I would say mostly.”
Immigration advocates, on the other hand, decried the move by the states and called on Congress and the administration to commit to DACA.
“Everyone who has seen DACA … should really be appalled by this legal low blow on the part of Texas. It’s nothing sort of shameful, it’s nothing short of repugnant,” said Kamal Essaheb, director of policy and advocacy at the National Immigration Law Center, on a call with reporters Friday.
Essaheb also blamed Trump for the whole episode, saying he protected DACA while going after its participants’ communities.
“These mixed messages have caused the situation that even allows Texas to consider what it did,” Essaheb said. “The Trump administration can and should shut this down.”
Members of Congress have introduced a handful of bipartisan proposals to make DACA permanent by law, thus nullifying the court challenge, but none have received a vote.
Thursday’s letter was signed by Paxton and the attorneys general of Alabama, Arkansas, Idaho, Kansas, Louisiana, Nebraska, South Carolina, Tennessee and West Virginia and the governor of Idaho.